• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Muggsy's Fine Dining

At Muggsy's Fine Dining, nestled in the heart of Jacksonville, IL, culinary excellence unfolds in an unpretentious setting. This gem specializes in hand-cut steaks, succulent seafood, and a diverse menu that caters to all tastes—from Italian to Asian dishes. Many patrons return for the celebrated prime rib, making it a favored choice for special occasions. The warm, welcoming staff and prompt service elevate the dining experience, ensuring each meal is memorable. Whether you're enjoying their renowned calamari or the delightful rainbow trout, Muggsy's combines fine dining with affordability, making every visit feel like a special occasion.

LOCATIONS

Welcome to Muggsy's Fine Dining, a hidden gem located at 230 S Mauvaisterre St, Jacksonville, IL 62650. If you're in search of a culinary experience that marries elegance with comfort, you’ve found your destination. Muggsy's showcases a delightful menu that includes prime cuts of steak, fresh seafood, and delectable sandwiches, making it a versatile choice for any palate.

The charm of Muggsy's extends beyond its menu. The ambiance is warm and inviting, perfect for celebrating special occasions or simply enjoying a casual meal. Dining here is often described as a celebration of great food and outstanding service. Many patrons, like Jessica Tvrdik-Fortin, return year after year to honor traditions, ensuring the Prime Rib dinner remains a staple in their anniversary celebrations.

  • Diverse Menu: According to Paul J Przepiorka, the array of options—from soups and salads to Asian and Italian dishes—makes Muggsy's a must-visit. It’s clear that this restaurant caters to a variety of tastes, ensuring that everyone finds something delightful to savor.
  • Exceptional Dishes: Guests rave about the calamari and prime rib, as noted by Stephanie Blocker. Muggsy’s commitment to quality means that each dish is crafted with care, promising delicious results every time.
  • Accommodating Service: The staff’s friendliness and efficiency have been consistently praised by diners like Trina Cesnik, who successfully hosted a large party without prior notice. This speaks volumes about their dedication to customer satisfaction.
  • Reasonable Prices: Despite its name suggesting extravagance, Muggsy's offers fine dining at surprisingly reasonable prices, as highlighted by Molly Nichols. Their exceptional dishes won't break the bank, making fine dining accessible to all.

Describing Muggsy's as merely a restaurant would be an understatement. It’s an experience. Whether you're indulging in their renowned rainbow trout or enjoying a comforting bowl of beer cheese soup, each visit warms the heart. The dedication of the team is palpable; their goal is to ensure that every guest leaves with a smile.

As you consider your next dining adventure, remember that Muggsy's Fine Dining is not just a place to eat—it’s a place to create memories. With its captivating menu, welcoming atmosphere, and exemplary service, it’s no wonder that Muggsy's has earned its place as a favorite in Jacksonville. So whether it's a special occasion or just a routine meal, Muggsy's is waiting to surprise and delight you with every bite.

START YOUR REVIEW OF Muggsy's Fine Dining
Jessica Tvrdik-Fortin
Jessica Tvrdik-Fortin

My husband I always celebrate our anniversary with a Prime Rib dinner so this being our 10th, we definitely didnt want to break tradition!! With it sometimes hard to find, we found Muggsys served it on the weekends so thought we would ...

Paul J Przepiorka
Paul J Przepiorka

Food and customer service was great. They have a variety of options from soups, salads, Asian, Italian and more. If youre ever in Jacksonville, this is a definite must go to for dinner.

Stephanie Blocker
Stephanie Blocker

Calamari and Primerib, need I say more? Ive been twice with family members and both times food was scrumptious and the server was delightful. My birthday is midmonth and Im hoping....

Molly Nichols
Molly Nichols

Ive dined here three times while traveling and every time has been great! The rainbow trout special tonight was outstanding and I have nothing but compliments for the service! While fine dining is in the name the prices are reasonable and you would not be turned away for wearing jeans.

Trina Cesnik
Trina Cesnik

Excellent service and food. Sat 20 people , including 7 teenagers without a reservation or prior notice and we had dinner served in less than 40 minutes!! Very friendly staff and fresh, homemade food.

Brian Donley
Brian Donley

A Rare Treat to find such a Magnificent Restaurant tucked away in older brick Building off the main throughfare of Jacksonville, IL. As a VegetarianVegan I am very particular of where and what I eat. Muggsys was a real treat. The food and ...

Sandy Lynch
Sandy Lynch

Great beer cheese soup! Our waitress was great. There was 10 of us and was on spot. Couldnt ask for better service. Thank you.

Jeff Decker
Jeff Decker

Favorite place in the area to eat. Hand cut steaks, seafood, chicken, chops, varied menu. Dont let the name fool you, the food is realang great BUT the price is outrageously inexpensive. Give them a try.